Skip to main content
Blues Harmonica logo

User Account

Username:*
Password:*
Forgot Your Password?

Visitor Menu

  • Sign Up
  • Sample Lesson #1
  • Sample Lesson #2
  • Student Recordings
  • Forums
Forums :: Ask Harmonica Expert Winslow Yerxa

2nd Harmonica

3 replies [Last post]
Fri, 02/27/2015 - 09:53
shirty
shirty's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/24/2015

Have just started to learn Harmonica using a Hohner Special C in key of C. If I decide to buy one in the key of G for Blues is it a big learning curve or a relatively easy transition to another key.

I am 69 and have been teaching myself acoustic Guitar with success but do not want to put my old brain/memory under too much of a strain. I am only thinking of one in the key of G because I like the deeper sound and I have read once I can play decent single notes bending is easier on the G.

I may add I will be playing on my own so the purchase will be for pleasure and not in order to play in the correct key with others.

Top
Fri, 02/27/2015 - 09:56
#1
shirty
shirty's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/24/2015
Amendment to original question

The Harmonica is a Hohner Special 20 in the key of C and not a Hohner Special C which I am sure does nt exist!

Top
Sun, 03/08/2015 - 09:20
#2
Expert Winslow Yerxa
Expert Winslow Yerxa's picture
Offline
Expert
Joined: 01/16/2010
Acquisition strategy for different keys of harmonica

A C harp (a harmonica in the key of C) is fine for your beginning bending explorations. Only the highest notes (Holes 7 thru 10) are easier to bend on low keyed harps like a G. The low notes might actually be harder on a G. (That said, everyone's oral geometry is different, and what's hard for one might be easy for another for that reason.)

I started on a C harp like most folks, then got an A, which is great for blues in E. When I first got a G I found it kind of daunting because the reeds responded so differently. They seemed kind of sluggish and slow to react. (The reeds in a G harp aren't much bigger than those in a C harp, but they have more weight on the ends so that they'll vibrate at a slower rate.)

I'd evaluate which key(s) to get next in a couple of different ways:

1) What keys are you most ikely to be playing in? Get the harps that will play in those keys, because those are the ones you'll use the most. (I assume you know about second position, where instead of playing the harp in its labeled key you play it in a key five steps up the scale, and use the draw chord in the first four holes as your "home" chord. For instance, you'd use that C harp to play in G).

2) Which keys will play similarly to the key(s) you're already familiar with? For instance, a G harp might be a big leap if you've only played a C harp. You might step down to that via an A harp (or perhaps also a Bb harp). And you could move up into the higher keys with the same approach: after a C harp, get comfortable on a D before going up to Eb, E, and F.

Top
Mon, 03/02/2015 - 05:51
#3
shirty
shirty's picture
Offline
Joined: 02/24/2015
2nd Harmonica

Thank you for the good and clearly stated advice.

I too now feel an A would be far better for me at the moment.

Top

Sign me up!

Full access to all lessons starts at $20/month! (with annual subscription)

Subscribe

Free Sample Lessons

After watching the BluesHarmonica.com overview video, try one of the lessons below to experience a lesson at BluesHarmonica.com.

  • Tongue Blocking Study 2 – This study is for the newer player or the player new to tongue blocking
  • Bending Study 5 – This is for the advanced player looking to improve their bending skills

Contributors

  • Aki Kumar
  • Joe Tartaglia
  • Gary Smith
  • Mark Hummel
  • Joe Filisko

Site Links

  • About David Barrett
  • Accredited Instructors
  • Links
  • Terms and Conditions
  • Contact Us
Hohner
© 2009 - 2025 David Barrett and the Harmonica Masterclass Co. for Bluesharmonica.com